Israel’s Supreme Court Ends Spy Agency Cellphone Tracking Of COVID-19 Infections

A man speaks on his mobile phone in the Mahane Yehuda market in Jerusalem in December. In the early days of the pandemic, Israel started using a mass security tool by itself individuals, tracking civilians smart phones to halt the spread of the coronavirus.

Maya Alleruzzo/AP

hide caption

toggle caption

Maya Alleruzzo/AP

A male speaks on his mobile phone in the Mahane Yehuda market in Jerusalem in December. In the early days of the pandemic, Israel began using a mass security tool on its own people, tracking civilians cellphones to halt the spread of the coronavirus.

Maya Alleruzzo/AP

Almost one year earlier, the Israeli federal government bought the Shin Bet domestic intelligence firm, usually charged with tracking Palestinian and Israeli extremists, to keep track of Israelis motions through their mobile phones. Those deemed to have been available in contact with validated infection carriers got text messages ordering them to quarantine.

JERUSALEM – Israels Supreme Court on Monday purchased an end to a controversial surveillance program to track COVID-19 infections through mobile phone area information, citing issues about the country spying on its own residents.

” What did you do last summertime? You do not remember? Do not stress, I, Big Brother, know what you did last summer season,” composed Amit in the ruling. “No, this is not a scary movie however rather the reality of our lives this past year.”

” The State of Israel is the only Western democracy that enlisted its private spy firm in the war versus the coronavirus pandemic,” wrote Justice Isaac Amit in the 73-page ruling.

In its judgment, the Supreme Court said there were concerns the spying could end up being permanent, which human contact tracers are more reliable at tracking COVID-19 infections than the security innovation. It ruled that as of March 14, Israel may just use mobile phone tracking in cases where Israelis refuse to comply with contact tracers.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stated the pandemic warranted the infringement on privacy. Israeli legislators and the head of Israels public health physicians association opposed the security program, citing personal privacy concerns. Some Israelis said they received text messages in mistake.

Amit compared the security program to Big Brother in George Orwells unique 1984 and alluded to the 1997 horror movie I Know What You Did Last Summer.

Do not worry, I, Big Brother, understand what you did last summertime,” composed Amit in the judgment.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stated the pandemic justified the infringement on privacy. Israeli legislators and the head of Israels public health doctors association opposed the monitoring program, mentioning personal privacy issues. Some Israelis stated they received text in error.